20 Comments
User's avatar
EKB ✑️ πŸ•Ž πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ's avatar

This is very interesting story of the Star of David. The Menorah actually had been the main symbol of judaism over the centuries. But the Star of David is easier to wear around your neck.

By the way, I do not wear the Magen David around my neck to remind me of who I am. It is there to let others know who I am. Especially in these days.

Elli Benaiah's avatar

Thanx. Yes, a Menora can be problematic around the neck, especially with burning candles… I know who I am, I am proud of who I am and I don’t need to show or hide from anyone. Writing about it all makes me even prouder.

Wolfgang's avatar

I can almost visualize the problematic results produced by burning ΧžΧ Χ•Χ¨Χ” candles in a Far Side cartoon created by Gary Larson.

EKB ✑️ πŸ•Ž πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ's avatar

well this definitely shows our age, since we know what the Far Side is....LOL

gayle lopes's avatar

Thank you for such a prompt response! I should have posted last month as I've been seeing this for awhile:).

Elli Benaiah's avatar

Dear Gayle. You are the second person who has brought this to my attention, which means that at least two people are reading me attentively. I know why this is happening, and will try and use a different (and better) way to edit. Thank you so much.

gayle lopes's avatar

Does anyone else reading these fascinating posts experience duplication? Within the article some paragraphs are repeated twice? Is this on my end or purposeful for some unknown reason by the author? Thanks.

Elli Benaiah's avatar

hope its fixed now…

Elli Benaiah's avatar

No, your`e not seeing double, and I am not testing to see whether your`e paying attention and I don`t was to doubly fascinate you. Its my shitty editing that is at fault here. Fixing it now, and thank you so much for the heads up.

Ruth Stroud's avatar

Wonderful piece, Elli! I just discovered it after following links back from today’s post on jam. I’ve come across so many β€œJewish” stars and swastikas in my travels and have always wondered about their origins and meaning. Thanks for this detailed discussion that fills in so many gaps in my knowledge.

Growing up, I heard stories of my father and his family’s narrow escape from Nazi Germany in the late 1930s and have seen many a Holocaust exhibit showing the ubiquitous yellow stars Jews were forced to wear during that horrific time. I was always reluctant to wear anything that identified me as Jewish, especially a mogen David, even though I’m not ashamed of who I am. The repurposing of sacred symbols to promote hatred is what scared me then and still does. Unfortunately, that seems to be as old as human history.

Elli Benaiah's avatar

I wear my star proudly through my writing.

Ruth Stroud's avatar

Beautifully put, Elli!

Susan Adams's avatar

An interesting story! Thank you πŸ™πŸ»

Elli Benaiah's avatar

Thank you for reading

User's avatar
Comment removed
Dec 8
Comment removed
Elli Benaiah's avatar

Actually you may be right. I am just not sure in solidarity of what… πŸ€”

User's avatar
Comment removed
Dec 8
Comment removed
Elli Benaiah's avatar

Doubt it. I am pretty sure I am the first Jewish person here since the last pogrom of the crusades

User's avatar
Comment removed
Dec 8
Comment removed
Elli Benaiah's avatar

Yes. And I thank them for giving me the idea…

User's avatar
Comment removed
Dec 8
Comment removed
Elli Benaiah's avatar

Will ask them and let you know…